I’m a liberal, and I am definitely not a fan of political propaganda drawn up by the sometimes out-of-touch administration and its mothership. Yet when some critics claimed that the latest talks of civic education planned to be rolled out in our primary and secondary schools are “brain-washing tools” , I can’t help to think that the teachers perhaps need to develop better and more sophisticated rebuttals than that.
No I’m not that naive to think that the administration isn’t planning to spoon-feed our young generation of the glorious prosperity of our state, ever. Every policy and every cent spent has an agenda, so the motive is definitely there. Though I believe whoever finding the way to “brain-wash” our generations Y & Z through a few hours of public school curriculum deserves a Nobel price.
Today’s youth is rebellious in nature, and it is not necessarily a bad thing. We have to embrace it no matter we like it or not. They are independent thinkers, though some may argue the logic of their thinking. One thing for sure, they will not take in any knowledge or thoughts as granted. So what are the chances of having them brain-washed by the most transparent form of patriotic education? Just look at the student riots everywhere from London to France to Seoul. These countries have a much longer standing as sovereign states, and they are still struggling of social unity across the classes. So what is Hong Kong afraid of being a territory known for our indifference in our nationality?
Come on, except the occasional declarations on immigration forms abroad, how often do Hong Kong people acknowledge our nationalities? We distance ourselves from mainland China because we cannot condone the many backwards policies and practices in the country, but we want their cash and the related business and job opportunities. We make an effort to explain to our foreign friends that we are from Hong Kong and it’s used to be a British colony, but we know it’s political incorrect to express any reminiscing sentiments over the colonization period. We know we are led by the supposedly independent Hong Kong government, though it is so lame-ducked and out-of-touch with the general public that it’s just unfashionable to even be sympathetic with the unimaginable duty it shoulders. So what’s left of us? A bunch of incredibly materialistic citizens who will flock to wherever that brings us instant gratification. In more cases than not, to Hong Kong, that means CASH.
That’s why if you think our youngest generation has not caught on with the trend, you are just kidding yourselves. Instead of brain-washing through civic education curriculum, just dangle a big fat deck of $500 notes in front of them. That will do the trick.
I might be a little young…but…i am a politic freak..so…Generally, I kidda agree with u..But i am feeling uncomfortable with the following two sentences.
“We distance ourselves from mainland China because we cannot condone the many backwards policies and practices in the country, but we want their cash and the related business and job opportunities. ”
i really don’t think that 1st, hk students distance theirselves from Mainland China because most of my hongkong classmates identify themselves clearly that they are Chinese. Chinese from Hong Kong though. 2nd, the policies in mainland china are not that backward…we r trying to catch up with you guys…and do u know how much we’ve improved in the last 30 years? i bet u do…3rd, if u thk we r backward…then why we have money? It is so weird that u need us while claiming u do not like us….creepy though.
And plus..i really don’t thk u should show off ur “colony” identity;”We make an effort to explain to our foreign friends that we are from Hong Kong and it’s used to be a British colony”, Because let me tell u…the foreigners will not respect u as a person, but treat u as a dog…
China has it’s problem..but China is also unique…i would really appreciate it if u don
t compare mainland china to HK or some other Western countries….cuz Hk is a developed city which has a population only over 1-3rd of SH, yet used by the British as a tool to make money for several decades…P.R. China is a developing country which has a population about 1,400,000,000, independent for over 50 years and has only in right order for 30 years. Honestly, i don’t thk u should make this comparision. Because after all, u guys r Chinese…an inconvenient truth right?
Hi Travis, first of all thank you very much for taking the time to share with me your thoughts. My tone throughout the entire post has been pretty sacastic and self critical in nature and you would know that it wasn’t my intention for sure to look down upon anyone, especially as you rightfully pointed out, that I am a Chinese as well. It’s exactly the type of identity crisis that I see with some of my generation of Hong Kong people that makes civil education particularly challenging for our youth today.
Oh…i was just in bad mood….probably not holding the same opinion right now…i was browsing ur blogs…though…i don’t thk i can see it back in mainland…so…good luck